The Project Greenlight message board
  The Project Greenlight Forum
  Oh You Writers - You'll never get respect, make money or sell a script (Page 1)

Post New Topic  Post A Reply
preferences | faq | search


This topic is 2 pages long:   1  2 
next newest topic | next oldest topic
Author Topic:   Oh You Writers - You'll never get respect, make money or sell a script
godcomplex
Junior Member
posted 04-10-2001 04:08 PM         Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
Most of us are not original enough to sell our ideas. The idea that good composers borrow and great composers steal pretty much summarizes most of us who are trying to get a break in Hollywood.

The truth #1 - most of us don't have "it." We don't have the talent, ingenuity or the connections to get our foot in the door and our projects off the ground.

Now I know there will be some of you that will get your panties in a bunch and say all kinds of self actualizing garbage. Keep on trying, maybe you'll get lucky. Maybe. Maybe not.

Truth #2 - Destiny is intangible. And since life isn't necessarily paint by number, anything that you've read or any promises made to you about your script, idea or any inner feeling you might have about your own talent simply doesn't change the fact that we don't know what tomorrow will bring.

With this written, you're probably thinking that I'm being quite cynical. On the contrary, I think that the good ones won't ever have to try nearly as hard as the rest of us. Stars shine. They can't avoid their own brilliance any more than the sun can stop shining.

So what's the point? The point is this: what's missing is something truly original in our writing. We've somehow missed the mark and most of us deep down know that we don't have "it." So re-evaluate that story you're working on and do something magical. Throw monkeys in it, make people fly, and for heaven's sake turn your stuff into something that resembles nothing you've ever seen.

IP: Logged

Lune12
Member
posted 04-10-2001 04:46 PM         Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
Dang what a downer. But I did see the Wizard of Oz with the flying monkeys and thought that was quite magical.

IP: Logged

Lune12
Member
posted 04-10-2001 04:50 PM         Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
And while I'm still here Mr. God Complex...don't you think there is a time in all successful person's lives where they question whether they had the so-called "it"? Where they second-guessed themselves and what their destiny would be?

IP: Logged

Lune12
Member
posted 04-10-2001 04:51 PM         Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
And that intangible shine--maybe that comes AFTER they are successful and can afford weekly facials, huh? But I see your point...

IP: Logged

julie
Member
posted 04-10-2001 04:58 PM         Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
I bet the writer of "Dude Where's My Car" would laugh godcomplex right out of written history. If that person can get their film made, so can any of the talented people here.

IP: Logged

Charmpri
Member
posted 04-10-2001 05:02 PM         Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
Originality - ha!

IP: Logged

backgroundgrrl
Member
posted 04-10-2001 05:04 PM         Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
You've convinced me. Guess I'll go shoot myself now that I have nothing to live for.

IP: Logged

justina
Member
posted 04-10-2001 05:05 PM         Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
quote:
Originally posted by backgroundgrrl:
You've convinced me. Guess I'll go shoot myself now that I have nothing to live for.

Can I borrow the gun after you?

I'll give it back.

IP: Logged

psichick
Member
posted 04-10-2001 05:05 PM         Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
pooey! A pox on you and your little monkeys, too!

IP: Logged

backgroundgrrl
Member
posted 04-10-2001 05:08 PM         Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
quote:
Originally posted by justina:
Can I borrow the gun after you?

I'll give it back.


I won't be needing it anymore, you are more than welcome to keep it.

Just tell my kids it was an accident, I don't them getting too upset.

IP: Logged

justina
Member
posted 04-10-2001 05:10 PM         Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
quote:
Originally posted by psichick:
pooey! A pox on you and your little monkeys, too!

hmm, maybe the answer is to throw poo.

IP: Logged

justina
Member
posted 04-10-2001 05:11 PM         Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
quote:
Originally posted by backgroundgrrl:
I won't be needing it anymore, you are more than welcome to keep it.

Just tell my kids it was an accident, I don't them getting too upset.


I'll tell them much like Christopher Walken tells little Bruce Willis about the watch.

I think if they're traumatized by that, at least they will acquire the magical "it" it takes to be successful.

IP: Logged

backgroundgrrl
Member
posted 04-10-2001 05:17 PM         Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
Justina -

Can you talk like Christopher Walken? That would be pretty traumatic to the poor kids.

Do you have your H/R posted anywhere? I'm curious as to what work you've done.

I know you aren't where you want to be, but I bet you've done pretty well.

IP: Logged

justina
Member
posted 04-10-2001 05:34 PM         Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
quote:
Originally posted by backgroundgrrl:
Justina -

Can you talk like Christopher Walken? That would be pretty traumatic to the poor kids.

Do you have your H/R posted anywhere? I'm curious as to what work you've done.

I know you aren't where you want to be, but I bet you've done pretty well.


Oh no, my biggest jobs were student films and the only paid gigs are extra work and not much of it.

I want to be SAG so bad.

But I did write and direct a short film (with a typical writer/director cameo as a crack whore). I'm going in to edit tonight.

IP: Logged

backgroundgrrl
Member
posted 04-10-2001 05:35 PM         Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
Was any of your extra work SAG? That's how I got in, I did my three union extra days.

IP: Logged

justina
Member
posted 04-10-2001 05:39 PM         Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
quote:
Originally posted by backgroundgrrl:
Was any of your extra work SAG? That's how I got in, I did my three union extra days.

i only did three jobs.

i'm thinking i'm gonna start doing something like ER regularly and get SAG that way. (praying for no strike)

If you know any better ways, please tell me.

Justina_Walford@warnerchappell.com

I'm desperate.

IP: Logged

backgroundgrrl
Member
posted 04-10-2001 05:48 PM         Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
Let me think and I'll mail you. If I recall your photo correctly, you are drop dead gorgous, so that can't hurt.

IP: Logged

justina
Member
posted 04-10-2001 05:50 PM         Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
quote:
Originally posted by backgroundgrrl:
Let me think and I'll mail you. If I recall your photo correctly, you are drop dead gorgous, so that can't hurt.

wow thanks.

(I hope you don't have me confused with 1take...who IS drop dead gorgeous)

IP: Logged

backgroundgrrl
Member
posted 04-10-2001 06:06 PM         Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
There are many women on this site who I think are ddg. I think my jaw hit the floor when I saw Proudleo's pix.

IP: Logged

Sachet
Member
posted 04-10-2001 08:09 PM         Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
Gee, you forgot about MY pix!

Hee, hee, ho, ho, ha, ha! I gotta stop this. It's making my poor wounded belly hurt!

IP: Logged

backgroundgrrl
Member
posted 04-10-2001 08:11 PM         Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
Come on Sachet, yours is such a given I didn't even need to mention them, right? Right?

IP: Logged

HoaxedTotem
Member
posted 04-10-2001 09:13 PM         Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote

WOW , what a HUGE observation G.C. !
}{ow long did it take you to figure that one out ?

And if in fact your post is not to be cynical then exactlly what purpose does it serve ?

And since your statement is so simplisticly
obvious , doesn't that sorta crumble your whole GodComplex delusion into nothing more than a speck of dust ?

IP: Logged

JulieMallen
Member
posted 04-10-2001 09:24 PM         Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
Everything in life has it's purpose.
So does this thread...
It inspires me to believe in myself more thank you for that!
Every one has a destiny to be fulfilled.
If you have the chance to dance or sit it out in life.
I hope you will always dance to your own music and sing your own sweet song.
We all look the way we are supposed to look.
We all have the gifts we were blessed with at birth.
It is up to us what we do with them.
There is nothing to stand in your way if you believe in yourself.
Succces to me is bringing a smile to another souls face.
What greater success can one have in life then have the gift of peace of mind...
Good health....
A loving famlily, friends and faith.
Success like beauty is in the eye of the beholder~
'-)

[This message has been edited by JulieMallen (edited 04-11-2001).]

IP: Logged

Sachet
Member
posted 04-11-2001 05:40 AM         Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
This is likely to be a long one, so prepare yourselves for another Sachet epic!

Mr. godcomplex, aside from the fact that your original post sounds like something ripped off from one of the articles at wordplayer.com, you're making an assumption I don't think is valid: that the goal in life should be achievement rather than process. This assumes that satisfaction and happiness ONLY comes from reaching goals, not from striving toward them.

I beg to differ!

The process of reaching down into oneself and pulling out experience and then molding into something tangible--in this case words on paper (or a computer screen)--is an incredibly powerful one. It internally affirms a person's right to live on the planet and say to the world, "I have something to say. Listen to me!"

We all know by now that there's little chance of ones vision remaining intact even if the screenplay manages to get produced, since filmmaking is a highly collaborative process where a number of people each interject their vision upon those words. It becomes a common vision, sometimes nothing at all like the one originally intended by the writer. In most cases.

So, whether a screenwriter is ever produced or not does not seem to me to be the end-all and be-all you're asserting. Having the satisfaction of printing out those 120 pages (or so), flopping them down on a desk, and saying, "here, I created this!" is--to my mind--the experience that creates the real satisfaction and a joy in being alive!

IP: Logged

HoaxedTotem
Member
posted 04-11-2001 05:54 AM         Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote

I agree w/ Sachet ,

}{ave you ever watched any of them commericals where they sell the best of the 80's hits ?

If you'll notice , where are all them groups now ? You never see them anymore .
But they did make it at least 1 x , and w/ all the crappy movies I've seen I have hope for even the worst writer on these boards
to get somethiing published in their life time .

IP: Logged

critical_critic
Member
posted 04-11-2001 06:35 AM         Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
God- we most certainly don't need you to remind us what we're incapable or capable of. You didn't tell us anything that any of us haven't thought of. This topic served absolutely no purpose, other than a practice for your typing skills (or as Sachet mentioned, copy and paste) You wasted an hour of your life being a jack ass, and I am wasting a minute of mine to tell you read Sachet's post 24 times.

Au revoir.
cc

IP: Logged

tocnkat
Member
posted 04-11-2001 06:38 AM         Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
The only failures in Hollywood are those that stop trying.

peace

IP: Logged

godcomplex
Junior Member
posted 04-11-2001 09:38 AM         Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
The post was what it was. I didn't cut and paste from any other source - I do have better things to do and a little more personal integrity than to "knowingly" rip off a seperate source to state my own opinion. But this proves my point further (not that I was trying to be original), but that it's hard to be original.

Success isn't about reaching goals. Don't be silly. I'm not so sure it's about process either. Finishing last does not make us winners. It just makes us people that happen to also run in the race.

If I was able to stir up any emotions within any of those that even took the time to read this post...GOOD. It takes all kinds to make the world go 'round, but only the most extreme send the world spinning on its axis.

Was this post slightly morbid? Sure. I'm not posting to get praise from fellow writers. If I wanted praise I would have posted flowers and poetry. I was trying to get you to re-evaluate your current projects and rethink...be revolutionary.

I think there should be a reformation of sorts in this industry. Not led by me...I'm not a leader of men (or women). I simply came to a place a few weeks ago where I realized that brilliant writing (again not by me - although I read some brilliant scripts in my opinion that didn't make the cut in this or any other contest) isn't enough.

Think about your intangible "it." It's formless; it is void of any single picture for proper definition. That is the frustrating idea to think about. We may never grasp "it." But there's a place in all of our minds that gets frustrated by this. If you're truly a writer capable of deeper thought (and I'm sure those that were angered by this post are capable of such thought) you know when you see that movie that moves you or read that book that makes you almost ashamed that you were trying to do the same thing.

Do you quit? NO! Of course not. You're incapable of quitting. You're moved to press on towards the intangible goal of feeling like you've made some sort of a difference. How? By placing words on paper...to inspire thought. Those that want to call me a jack ass...then I'm a jack ass. If writing those kinds of insults makes you feel better, fine. It doesn't bother me. Defending myself probably won't change your minds.

IP: Logged

backgroundgrrl
Member
posted 04-11-2001 09:50 AM         Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
quote:
Originally posted by godcomplex:
you know when you see that movie that moves you or read that book that makes you almost ashamed that you were trying to do the same thing.

Interesting.

I've never had that feeling. When I read or see something that is good, it just gives me more confidence in my own work.

It's bad writing that gets me down.

IP: Logged

Smurf
Member
posted 04-11-2001 09:59 AM         Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
quote:
Originally posted by godcomplex:
Most of us are not original enough to sell our ideas. The idea that good composers borrow and great composers steal pretty much summarizes most of us who are trying to get a break in Hollywood.

The truth #1 - most of us don't have "it." We don't have the talent, ingenuity or the connections to get our foot in the door and our projects off the ground.

Now I know there will be some of you that will get your panties in a bunch and say all kinds of self actualizing garbage. Keep on trying, maybe you'll get lucky. Maybe. Maybe not.

Truth #2 - Destiny is intangible. And since life isn't necessarily paint by number, anything that you've read or any promises made to you about your script, idea or any inner feeling you might have about your own talent simply doesn't change the fact that we don't know what tomorrow will bring.

With this written, you're probably thinking that I'm being quite cynical. On the contrary, I think that the good ones won't ever have to try nearly as hard as the rest of us. Stars shine. They can't avoid their own brilliance any more than the sun can stop shining.

So what's the point? The point is this: what's missing is something truly original in our writing. We've somehow missed the mark and most of us deep down know that we don't have "it." So re-evaluate that story you're working on and do something magical. Throw monkeys in it, make people fly, and for heaven's sake turn your stuff into something that resembles nothing you've ever seen.


Tell me one movie that is original and not based on ideas of other movies or ideas of novels, short stories, and etc... Tell me one, just one.

[This message has been edited by Smurf (edited 04-11-2001).]

IP: Logged

godcomplex
Junior Member
posted 04-11-2001 10:23 AM         Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
quote:
Originally posted by Smurf:
Tell me one movie that is original and not based on ideas of other movies or ideas of novels, short stories, and etc... Tell me one, just one.

[This message has been edited by Smurf (edited 04-11-2001).]


Pi

IP: Logged

Sachet
Member
posted 04-11-2001 10:28 AM         Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
Uhuru, is that you, you naughty girl? You're the only person I recall who's used the term "God complex." And now that I look at the writing a little closer... You can take the pen away from the girl but you can't take the girl away from the pen? What? Just proved your point, didn't I? Hee hee!

Since my screenplay was the last you'd started reading (assuming you're Uh in drag), fear and trepidation is slivering down my jellied spine. Well, if so, can't say I disagree. I know my message(s) and even story aren't hackneyed, but have always had fear that I've told it in a rather ho hum manner.

And I just had an experience of seeing what low stakes will do to a story.

Or are you talking about imagery and HOW one conveys internal or external states?

Watched "Judging Amy" last night and once again was captivated by ways the writers were able to convey emotions, in particular. Especially at the end. Clear, intense, felt, and original.

But you're dead wrong that folks won't get there. Maybe those without the drive will give up and turn to other pursuits. But the committed will perservere and keep learning and growing, discriminating, polishing and refining.

And you really should go to wordplayer.com and read that article. It was written by Terry Rossio (Mask of Zorro, etc.) and was even more brutal than you were.

Of course, it too was a ruse!

IP: Logged

dharris
Member
posted 04-11-2001 10:29 AM         Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
quote:
Originally posted by godcomplex:
Pi

Forget what I said, I was thinking of the wrong movie.

[This message has been edited by dharris (edited 04-11-2001).]

IP: Logged

KarmaMarie
Member
posted 04-11-2001 10:33 AM         Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
Clever, very clever! Thanks for the pep talk GC! For those who were impassioned and motivated to prove the comments wrong, BRAVO!

For those who conceded...shame on you! You know you are more talented than all that! Isn't it when one is challenged that they become their own biggest supporter?!

Have some confidence in yourself and your ability and use this "kick in the butt" to prove all the doubters wrong!

YOU CAN DO IT!!!

LY
K

IP: Logged

godcomplex
Junior Member
posted 04-11-2001 10:36 AM         Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote

[This message has been edited by godcomplex (edited 04-11-2001).]

IP: Logged

queenie
Member
posted 04-11-2001 10:40 AM         Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
I think my SPs are fairly original, considering that there's really nothing new under the sun... I know it sounds egotistical but I have to believe in myself or else I'd never have the courage to do anything. Besides, I'd rather be called egotistical than a coward any day. Who wouldn't?

IP: Logged

godcomplex
Junior Member
posted 04-11-2001 10:42 AM         Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
quote:
Originally posted by Sachet:
Uhuru, is that you, you naughty girl? You're the only person I recall who's used the term "God complex." And now that I look at the writing a little closer... You can take the pen away from the girl but you can't take the girl away from the pen? What? Just proved your point, didn't I? Hee hee!

Since my screenplay was the last you'd started reading (assuming you're Uh in drag), fear and trepidation is slivering down my jellied spine. Well, if so, can't say I disagree. I know my message(s) and even story aren't hackneyed, but have always had fear that I've told it in a rather ho hum manner.

And I just had an experience of seeing what low stakes will do to a story.

Or are you talking about imagery and HOW one conveys internal or external states?

Watched "Judging Amy" last night and once again was captivated by ways the writers were able to convey emotions, in particular. Especially at the end. Clear, intense, felt, and original.

But you're dead wrong that folks won't get there. Maybe those without the drive will give up and turn to other pursuits. But the committed will perservere and keep learning and growing, discriminating, polishing and refining.

And you really should go to wordplayer.com and read that article. It was written by Terry Rossio (Mask of Zorro, etc.) and was even more brutal than you were.

Of course, it too was a ruse!


Nope. Not Uhuru. But it's funny that you'd think that someone would post under and alias to make a point. Maybe that part is true, but the identity of the writer is definitely wrong.

I will read the article though. Sounds interesting.

IP: Logged

JulieMallen
Member
posted 04-11-2001 10:52 AM         Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
It is great to come back the next day after you have read something late the night before.
I believe in you people!>>>>>>>>>>
If you have the desire you can become what ever you want.
How long it takes you to get there is up to fate perserverence and how well you learn your craft.
I love reading you people!
Have a great day~
;-)

IP: Logged

uhuru1701
Member
posted 04-11-2001 11:12 AM         Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
NO, THIS ISN'T ME!!!!!! MY THING IS NOT BUMMING PEOPLE OUT OR DISCOURAGING THEM. MY THING IS TRYING TO UPLIFT PEOPLE AND HELP THEM BELIEVE THAT THEY CAN ACHIEVE ANYTHING. ASK JULIEMALLEN ABOUT THE KIND OF CRITIQUE I DO. SHE CAN TELL YOU THAT I ONLY WANT TO HELP MAKE THE PERSON DO BETTER.


quote:
Originally posted by Sachet:
Uhuru, is that you, you naughty girl? You're the only person I recall who's used the term "God complex." And now that I look at the writing a little closer... You can take the pen away from the girl but you can't take the girl away from the pen? What? Just proved your point, didn't I? Hee hee!

Since my screenplay was the last you'd started reading (assuming you're Uh in drag), fear and trepidation is slivering down my jellied spine. Well, if so, can't say I disagree. I know my message(s) and even story aren't hackneyed, but have always had fear that I've told it in a rather ho hum manner.

And I just had an experience of seeing what low stakes will do to a story.

Or are you talking about imagery and HOW one conveys internal or external states?

Watched "Judging Amy" last night and once again was captivated by ways the writers were able to convey emotions, in particular. Especially at the end. Clear, intense, felt, and original.

But you're dead wrong that folks won't get there. Maybe those without the drive will give up and turn to other pursuits. But the committed will perservere and keep learning and growing, discriminating, polishing and refining.

And you really should go to wordplayer.com and read that article. It was written by Terry Rossio (Mask of Zorro, etc.) and was even more brutal than you were.

Of course, it too was a ruse!


IP: Logged

godcomplex
Junior Member
posted 04-11-2001 11:16 AM         Edit/Delete Message   Reply w/Quote
quote:
Originally posted by uhuru1701:
[b]NO, THIS ISN'T ME!!!!!! MY THING IS NOT BUMMING PEOPLE OUT OR DISCOURAGING THEM. MY THING IS TRYING TO UPLIFT PEOPLE AND HELP THEM BELIEVE THAT THEY CAN ACHIEVE ANYTHING. ASK JULIEMALLEN ABOUT THE KIND OF CRITIQUE I DO. SHE CAN TELL YOU THAT I ONLY WANT TO HELP MAKE THE PERSON DO BETTER.


[/B]


Oh come on Uhuru, just admit it. We're one in the same. Maybe two sides of the same coin. If people want to believe I'm you and you're me what can we say that would change their opinions...they'll always be suspicious. Fine, I admit it.

IP: Logged


This topic is 2 pages long:   1  2 

All times are PT (US)

next newest topic | next oldest topic

Administrative Options: Close Topic | Archive/Move | Delete Topic
Post New Topic  Post A Reply
Hop to:

Contact Us | Project Greenlight

Powered by Infopop www.infopop.com © 2000
Ultimate Bulletin Board 5.46a

The Greenlight Forums are a place for Contestants, Reviewers, and Members to interact. We hope that you enjoy the community. Please remember, however, that use of the Forums (and use of the greenlight Site in general) is subject to the greenlight Terms of Service and Privacy Policy. In addition, while we're glad to see greenlighters pitching in to support each other, please remember that the posts you see here (whether about Submissions, the Official Rules, or other topics) represent the views of individual visitors, and do not represent Project Greenlight's views or opinions. For the final word on the Official Rules, read the Official Rules! You can also find helpful information in the Frequently Asked Questions area of the Site.